Reviewer's feedback

Scientific Reviewers Give Feedback

For every manuscript posted on eiRxiv, a scientific reviewer will be invited to provide constructive and supportive feedback

The goal of this feedback is to:

  • Celebrate what students did well in research and writing.
  • Kindly point out areas to improve so the manuscript can be even better.

 

eiRxiv reviewers’ scientific feedback will be posted publicly for transparency, collaboration, and faster sharing of scientific knowledge. 

Responding to Scientific Feedback

After the reviewer’s scientific feedback is posted on eiRxiv, student authors can read it carefully and think about what changes might make their research stronger.

*Please note that acceptance to eiRxiv does not automatically mean your manuscript will be accepted by JEI or another journal. JEI and other journals may also have stricter guidelines for manuscript content and formatting. Please review and follow all of the guidelines for your target journal before you submit your manuscript to them.